RTRRO

type

status

date

The Most Magical Thing in Your Mailbox

Bringing that book inside? Total ritual. If you were a kid, you needed two hands—no way you could hold it one-handed. You’d plop it on the living room floor like it was a family heirloom, not just a list of toys. And the smell? Oh man, that smell. Fresh ink, cheap paper, and… possibility. Adults might call it “lignin and cellulose breaking down,” but to us? It was Santa’s workshop in a book. You’d take a big whiff and think, “Okay. The holidays are here.”

The pages had a feel all their own. Thin, but glossy enough that every toy glowed under the lamp in your cozy den. Flipping through them made this soft whir—like the sound of daydreams. And it wasn’t like scrolling a webpage, y’know? No endless, weightless stream of images. This was real. You could feel how many things you wanted just by turning the pages. A hundred in, and there were still hundreds more to go.

Dog-earing a page? That was a commitment. Fold that corner sharp, and you were saying, “This. This is mine (hopefully).” To yourself, to your parents, maybe even to Santa. It wasn’t just a mark—it was a wish you could touch.

That book stayed put, too. On the coffee table, on your bedroom floor—from the day it arrived until Christmas morning. It was a companion. You’d go back to pages, second-guess your choices, and argue with your siblings over why your circled toy was “way cooler” than theirs. By December 25? Its corners were soft, its spine cracked, and it looked less like a catalog and more like a well-loved novel. Every crease, every smudge? Proof you’d studied it like it was a test.

The Art of the Perfect Wish List

First pass through the book? Total sprint. You’d fly through pages, eyes wide, thinking “I need that! And that! Wait, what’s that?!” But the real work—the serious business of making a wish list? That took time. Strategy. And the right tool: usually a freshly sharpened pencil or a fine-tipped pen, nothing that’d bleed through the thin paper and ruin the toy picture on the other side.

You couldn’t circle everything. That was amateur hour. Your parents (or Santa) would see it and go, “Nice try, kid—focus.” So you had to curate.

Each circle meant something. A clean, confident loop around the LEGO Blacktron Starship? That was you wanting adventure, wanting to build something cool. A shaky little circle around the Barbie Dream Camper? That was vulnerability—you wanted a whole imaginary world to play in. You’d circle the big-ticket item, sure: the Nintendo Entertainment System Action Set, the Power Wheels Jeep. But you knew that was a long shot. A dream you barely dared to say out loud.

So you’d hedge your bets. Throw in smaller stuff that felt possible: a new set of Micro Machines, a G.I. Joe with kung-fu grip, a Skip-It. Stuff that didn’t make your heart race as much, but still made you smile.

This was serious, personal work. Pages got marked, unmarked, then marked again. Sometimes a single page held a war of wants: Do I get the whole Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set, or the Technodrome playset? You couldn’t have both—that was greed. The Wish Book taught you real life stuff, weirdly enough. Scarcity. The pain of picking one thing over another.

And when you were done? That catalog became your script for the most important letter of the year: the one to Santa. You’d copy your circled items onto paper, handwriting as neat as you could get it, like that book was a direct line to the North Pole. It was the bible for your holiday wishes.

The Toy Section: A Paper Paradise

If you were a kid in the 80s or 90s, the toy section was the best part of the catalog. No doubt about it.

One minute you’re looking at boring sensible sweaters and corduroy pants. The next page? Boom. Color. Mess. Fun.

Those pages were full. Every little spot had a toy. Action figures stuck mid-fight. LEGO castles with tiny knights inside. Barbie smiling from her plastic mansion’s window.

It wasn’t just a picture of a toy in a box. It was a look at the fun you’d have.

The action figure pages? They made you want to use your imagination. Whole armies of G.I. Joes and Cobras lined up against each other. They had tanks, jets, even aircraft carriers that took two whole pages.

You could almost hear the tiny plastic booms.

You didn’t just want the figure. You wanted the whole fight. The story right there on the shiny paper.

Then the LEGO pages. Oh, c’mon—we all lost our minds over the LEGO pages. Huge castles with working drawbridges, sprawling space stations with detachable pods, pirate ships ready to sail the sea of your living room carpet. These weren’t just toys—they were projects. Promises of quiet, focused hours spent following instructions to build something with your own hands. You’d stare at the pictures, trace the bricks with your finger, already building it in your head.

Video game pages? That was the holy grail. This was where the future lived. Seeing the sleek gray box of the Super Nintendo or the cool black curves of the Sega Genesis? Felt like looking at technology from another planet. The screenshots—Super Mario World, Sonic the Hedgehog—were electric. Tiny, pixelated windows into worlds of speed and adventure that felt urgent, like you needed to be there.

The descriptions had jargon: “blast processing,” “16-bit graphics.” You didn’t understand a word of it, but you knew it was important. The price? Always a scary three-digit number—way too adult. That page got dog-eared the most, but with the least hope. You’d look at it and think, “Maybe next year.”

And Barbie? Oh yeah. Pages and pages of her. Her friends, her houses, her cars, that insane wardrobe. The Barbie Dream House? A marvel of pink plastic. The Barbie Corvette? Peak cool. It was its own universe—flip the page, and you’re in a world of endless parties, dream jobs, and perfect hair.

More Than Toys: A Time Capsule of 90s Life

As you got a little older, you’d branch out. You still spent most of your time in the toy section, but you’d peek at the other parts—weird, fascinating worlds of “adult life” as Sears saw it. That catalog? It was more than toys. It was a time capsule of a very specific era.

The electronics section? A museum of obsolete tech. Chunky boomboxes yelling “Mega Bass,” portable CD players with “45-Second Anti-Skip Protection,” Walkmans that were the height of cool. Transparent phones with neon insides, camcorders that sat on your shoulder like a friendly parrot. An IBM computer—monitor a whole foot deep—for $1419. Looking back now? Wild. How fast that “future” became old news.

Fashion? A rollercoaster of questionable choices. Acid-wash jeans, neon windbreakers, oversized sweatshirts covered in puffy paint—all presented like they were high fashion. And matching family pajamas? Every year. A smiling family, from dad down to the toddler, all in the same festive flannel. Dorky? Absolutely. But kinda sweet, too.

You’d flip past basketball hoops and rollerblades into home decor—floral couches, wood-paneled microwaves—and get a little glimpse into the world your parents lived in. The Wish Book wasn’t just about what we wanted to buy. It was about who we wanted to be. A mirror of our habits, our desires, even our bad taste.

Now? The Wish Book’s gone. A casualty of a world that chose the sterile convenience of digital carts over the magic of a thousand-page book. That experience—the ritual, the quiet joy of sitting with that huge thing and dreaming? It’s just a memory. For those of us lucky enough to live it, anyway. There’s a sadness to that—missing a shared thing we all had.

But it was never just about the stuff. It was about the wanting. The quiet, hopeful season of waiting. For a few months, you believed everything you ever wanted was somewhere between those front and back covers. That thud on the doorstep? It was the start of magic.

It was such a big part of holiday traditions. What’s the one thing you circled every single year but never got? Share that memory—I’d love to hear it.

The Wish Book: Remembering the Thousand-Page Bible of Holiday Nostalgia

The Most Magical Thing in Your Mailbox

The Art of the Perfect Wish List

The Toy Section: A Paper Paradise

More Than Toys: A Time Capsule of 90s Life